12 Best Shoe Polishes in 2017

Whether you consider it a bit of a chore or you like to do it to ensure a job well done, when you polish your shoes or boots, you will aim to complete the task right the first time so you do not have to do it again.

The regular use of the best shoe polish is necessary to properly maintain your footwear, keeping them looking their best no matter how often they are worn.

Our shoes go through a great deal of strain and have to support the full weight of the body no matter what the weather or the extent of use. As a result, they may occasionally need a little TLC.

The quality of the shoe polish that you use can determine its effectiveness, so it is important to use the right type of shoe polish. By using the right polish according to the shoe material, you can make sure your shoes last and remain looking like new for as long as possible.

Top 12 Shoe Polishes Complete Chart

DesignNameTypeColor VarietiesRating (1-5)
  1. Dr. Martens Unisex Wonder Balsam Shoe Polish Wax No 4.7
  2. Fiebing’s Yellow Saddle Soap Wax No 4.7
  3. FRYE Leather Conditioning Cream Cream No 4.7
  4. Tarrago Self Shine Cream Kit Cream Yes 4.7
 5. Meltonian Shoe Cream Polish, Black Cream Yes 4.5
  6. Kiwi Deluxe Shine Kit Wax No 4.5
  7. Tarrago Shoecream Jar 50Ml Cream Yes 4.5
  8. Kiwi Brown Shoe Polish Wax Yes 4.5
  9. Pink Miracle Bottle – Shoe Cleaner Cream No 4.4
  10. Lincoln Shoe Wax Polish Wax Yes 4.4
  11. Kiwi Color Shine Liquid Yes 4.3
  12. TRG the One Shoe Cream Cream Yes 4.2

Types of Shoe Polish

There are a number of different types of shoe polish available on the market and to ensure that you use the best shoe polish, it is necessary to understand the different types and the materials for which they are suitable.

  • Cream – A cream shoe polish will often be available in a color that matches the shoe, so that its use will not only create shine but it will also enhance the original color. They can be applied with a sponge and also have the added benefit of being able to condition leather to keep it supple and make it last longer.
  • Wax – Wax shoe polish is probably the most easily recognized of all the shoe polishes and has a distinctive smell. It is applied using a stiff bristled brush and is often the best way to achieve a high shine.
  • Liquid – Liquid shoe polish will usually come in a bottle that comprises a sponge applicator for ease of use. After application, it will require buffing to get the required shine. It will usually be neutral so that it is not necessary to use one that matches the color of the shoes.

How to Achieve the Most Benefit from Shoe Polish

  • Prepare before you begin the process of polishing your shoes by covering the area in which you intend to work. Spread out newspapers or an old drop cloth on the surface on which you intend to work before even opening the polish.
  • If you intend to use gloves, make sure that these are the close-fitting latex kind, which will be less likely to hinder the task.
  • Ensure that your shoes are clean and dry before commencing use of the shoe polish. Take this opportunity to check the shoes for any damage to the shoes, such as scuffs or holes, which cannot be rectified with polish. Rectify any damage before proceeding with the shoe polish process.
  • With many examples of shoe polish, it is not necessary to use a lot at a time as this can often result in streaks. Use it sparingly to achieve the best result.

Top 4 Best Shoe Polish Reviews

1. Dr. Martens Unisex Wonder Balsam Shoe Polish

This Dr Martens polish was purchased for the purpose of polishing both women’s and men’s Dr Martens boots as well as leather boots from a different brand. They were all pretty creased and scratched and one pair had noticeable scuffs on the toes.

The polish comes in a tin much like other polishes that is recognizable from the past, but the distinctive smell of traditional shoe polishes was not present. It actually smelled quite pleasant, which probably has something to do with the balsam as listed as one of the ingredients.

It is easy to use as the applicator is in the lid and it is not necessary to use any other cloth or brush. The scratches in the leather that seemed to be significant were made to disappear as if they had never been there in the first place, but this polish got rid of them and the leather actually looked a deeper black than before. The results following use of this polish was impressive as it completely got rid of the scuffs and it is worthy of the history of the brand name.

2. Fiebing’s Yellow Saddle Soap

Fiebing’s Yellow Saddle Soap is suitable for leather no matter what the color, so this was a draw in deciding to test its efficacy. This is especially beneficial for shoes of a color less common than black, such as brown or red.

We used this polish on leather shoes of several colors that had several scrapes near the soles. The color made them show up quite prominently, and made them look quite unsightly. After using this polish, the marks were gone and there was just a nice sheen to the leather that left them looking like new.

Similar marks on a leather car seat disappeared in the same manner and also cleaned off some water streaks that had subsisted for a while following a drink spillage. An excellent shoe polish that can also benefit other leather products to remove marks effectively.

3. FRYE Leather Conditioning Cream

The design of the tin of this Frye Leather Conditioning Cream was immediately striking straight out of the box, as it appears quite old school while still being modern.

Using a cloth to rub this cream into leather boots, we sought to test how effective it would be to provide protection against wet weather on the basis that rainwater will usually leave white marks. After using this Frye cream, the leather remained free from any marks even after they got wet.

It was an impressive result bearing in mind that not very much of the cream was used.

The boots definitely felt more flexible after using the cream, so it was also applied to a leather bag that felt a bit stiff. The leather looked darker and the bag was much more supple and more comfortable to use.

Definitely a product that is recommended to condition and polish leather goods.

4. Tarrago Self Shine Cream Kit

This Tarrago polish is much like the examples that were commonly used as standard years ago. It is more like a liquid than a wax so we worked in a prepared area where the shoes were also left to dry.

The sponge applicator is included so no other accessories were needed.

It is difficult to know how much to use, but on the premise that it is easier to add than remove, we started with a small amount and that is all that was necessary.

The shoes used were thought to be black before commencing use of this polish. Only after seeing the intense black result was it clear to see how faded they were. This is the best shoe polish as it is easy to use and creates a great looking shoe.