12 Best Mattress Toppers in 2017

We all love a good night’s sleep, but nobody likes to shop for a new mattress. There are so many choices and it is difficult to spend so much money on something that you aren’t even sure you will like!

Whether you have recently purchased a new mattress or have an old one that isn’t quite ready to head to the donation bin, a mattress topper might be the solution to your problem. These simple pads are an inexpensive way to make your current mattress more comfortable, but which one should you choose?

Unfortunately, manufacturers went a little wild, and you can now buy a topper that’s just as exotic as those $2000 mattresses. While the selection can be difficult, our experts have combined a list of the best mattress topper choices to help you get a better night’s sleep without emptying your pockets.

Top 12 Mattress Toppers Comparison Table

DesignNameTypeThicknessRating (1-5)
  1. Sleep Innovations 4-inch Plush Support Gel Memory Foam Mattress Memory Foam 4-inches 4.7
  2. Red Nomad – Full Size 2 Inch Thick Memory Foam 2-inches 4.6
  3. Zen Bamboo Ultra Soft Bamboo Mattress Topper Down Alternative NA 4.6
  4. Milliard Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper Gel/Foam 2-inches 4.6
  5. Pure Green 100% Natural Latex Mattress Topper Latex Foam 2-inches 4.5
6. Duck & Goose Co Plush Durable Premium Hotel Quality Mattress Topper Down Alternative 2-inches 4.5
7. Sure2Sleep 3 Pound High Density Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper Gel/Foam 2-inches 4.5
8. Beautyrest Geo Incline Elevation Topper Foam Varies4.3
  9. Best Price Mattress 4-Inch Memory Foam Mattress Topper Foam Mix 4-inches 4.3
  10. LUCID 2-inch 5-Zone Lavender Memory Foam Mattress Topper Memory Foam 2-inches 4.3
  11. Zinus 4 Inch Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress Topper Memory Foam 4-inches 4.3
  12. Firm Conventional Polyurethane Foam MattressPad Foam 5-inches 4.2

Why Do You Need a Topper?

Most folks with new mattresses don’t buy toppers to go with them. In other words, if you are purchasing a pad or topper, it’s probably due to the fact you have a bad mattress or back. Hopefully, it’s not both although if it is, we still have something for you in our table. Think about why you need to purchase a topper along with any medical conditions you may have before digging into the different styles.

A couple of overlooked aspect of toppers are warranties and something called off-gassing. You aren’t going to find many toppers with lengthy warranties although some will offer up a 10-year guarantee. Off-gassing is something you could only experience with particular types of pads, and you’ll know it immediately as it’s an odor that tends to come along with certain types of foam.

Topper Styles

One of the leading causes of confusion in the mattress topper happens over how manufacturers describe their products. It’s not uncommon to see one labeled as a “Memory Foam Gel” topper although you’ll quickly find out all is not what it seems. While most of our pick are hybrid, there is a difference in the materials.

  • Memory Foam – This is the most popular style at the moment and the most affordable unless it’s built with a mixture of materials. It’s a form of polyurethane called viscoelastic with low resistance which conforms to your body but regains its shape after use.
  • Gel – When you see a manufacturer use the term “gel” when peddling a mattress pad, it’s not made of gel. Some will have a thin layer on top while others are infused with memory foam. When it’s a layer, it helps with cooling as memory foam get warmer than other materials.
  • Latex – Latex-based foam does share a few traits with memory foam, but has more bounce and less localized when it comes to compression. Most toppers made from latex are 100% although you occasionally get hybrids that incorporate gel or foam.
  • Down Alternative – Love the feel of a feather bed, but not what’s inside? People have used feathers for hundreds of years, but now consumers with allergies can opt for a down alternative topper. If the quality is top-notch, you may not be able to tell the difference between the two aside from a cheaper price tag.

Sizing

The size of mattress toppers usually lines up with your bed. That’s the beauty of standards, so you can rest easy when dealing with size – most of the time. There are a few oddball measurements to deal with although that’s not the main issue with sizing. It’s your sheets, so hopefully you haven’t grown too attached to your favorite set.

Depending on the size of the mattress topper you choose, you may need to purchase new sheets. 2-inches is the minimum for any type of foam, gel or hybrid although some pads come in larger sizes. If you already have tight sheets and no mattress pad, you’ll want to go ahead and plan on a new set. On the other hand, feather and down alternative toppers don’t take up nearly as much space.

Top 5 Best Mattress Topper Reviews

1. Sleep Innovations Plush Support Mattress Topper

Remember what we said about new sheets? You’ll need them for Sleep Innovations Plush Support Mattress Topper as it clocks in at 4-inches high. It also has an interesting, classic design that allows you to use it in two different ways.

Remember those old-school egg crate mattress pads? They aren’t quite as prevalent today as they once were, but you can still scoop one up without looking too hard. Sleep Innovations has taken that style into the modern age by making their topper smooth on one side and “crated” on the other. Basically, you get a different feel depending on which way it’s turned. It’s made from a blend of gel memory foam with fiber-fill, the former takes up 3-inches of room while the latter is 1”. It’s also going to be easy to clean if an accident happens considering you can toss it in the washer and dryer.

This massive topper comes with a 10-year warranty, and while it’s only available in a 4-inch height, you can choose from twin, full, queen, king or California king. The company also says it can stretch up to 18-inches deep, so there’s some wiggle room as well.

2. Red Nomad Full Size Premium Mattress Pad

Red Nomad’s toppers are for people that take their sleep seriously. Their Premium Mattress Pad is made here in the USA and breezed through the CertiPUR-US certification program. It’s also one of the pricier pads to make the grade, but you get what you pay for with this one – quality.

Every mattress pad on our list takes you comfort to the next level, of this, there is no doubt. Some tend to be hotter than others although that will not be a problem with Red Nomad’s Premium model. The company designed this one to keep you cool regardless of the season with a unique polymer worked into the memory foam. It’s not a hybrid either; there is no gel involved in the build, just thick foam which will send you into a deep slumber as soon as you hit the sheets.

While this topper comes in all the standard sizes and twin XL, it’s built to be 1” shorter on all four sides. This helps it fit better with if you’re using fitted sheets, and something to consider depending on the rest of your bedding. You also get a choice when it comes to height with a 2”, 3” or 4” topper.

3. Zen Bamboo Ultra Soft Bamboo Mattress Topper

Now we’re going to take a look at our first down alternative topper which hails from a company called Zen Bamboo. If you have allergies and are not fond of thick padding on your mattress, you’ll want to think about picking up this affordable mattress pad.

This is one of the simpler picks on our list as there are no exotic elements used in the construction of the topper – it’s just cotton, bamboo fibers and down alternative fill. Bamboo has become a popular choice for its cooling properties, so sleeping on this topper will keep you fresh and comfy, unlike foam that tends to hug your body while you sleep. It’s built to last and won’t get lump after a few years thanks to double-needle baffle boxes which keep the fill in place. Worried about having to head to the dry cleaners? Have no fear as you can toss this topper in the washer and dryer as well.

Consumers looking for the best mattress topper for support will want to look elsewhere. The Zen Bamboo’s built for comfort, so it’s cushy and the exact opposite of foam and similar materials. This one is available in the usual sizes along with twin XL and California King.

4. Millard’s Premium Mattress Pad

Millard’s Premium Mattress Pad is not going to be light and fluffy like a filled topper; this one is for support. It’s an excellent choice if you need a durable solution for your bed and you’ll be pleased with the density of this one if you want one that will last.

Like other bedding pads, the Millar Gel Memory Foam Topper is not exactly true to size. It’s a fuzz smaller on all sides to accommodate your sheets better, so you may not need to upgrade your fitted sheets with this model. The build quality’s made from a mix of memory foam with gel which makes it cooler than some that go with 100% foam. It comes in one height at 3-inches and has a cover made from bamboo fibers which help cut back on allergies, dust, and other nasties.

While we do dig this topper, off-gassing is something you should always consider when choosing the best mattress topper. You are likely to experience some with the Millard Premium Pad although it should clear up quickly and you can always speed the process up if needed.

5. Pure Green 100% Natural Latex Topper

Our first real latex mattress pad comes from the minds at Sleep on Latex. Despite its simple style, it’s one of the pricier options we came across, but one that’s worth it. This one’s made from 100% latex, which gives it a leg up hybrids in several areas.

We’re big fans of latex mattress toppers, especially ones that use natural latex. This one has no fillers or synthetics and has air chambers across the length of the pad which allows it to breathe and cuts down on the weight. As for the firmness, it’s rated at a medium measuring a 30 ILD on the scale. Pure Green’s topper is hefty, but will last longer than a regular foam or gel-infused pad and certified from Greenguard Gold, Oeko-Tex and EcoInstitut.

The Pure Green 100% Natural Latex Topper is available sized from a twin XL all the way up to a Cali king. You can also choose between three different heights with a 1”, 2” or 3” topper. The only downside would be the latex smell, which may or may not affect you – it varies across the board.