12 Best Cold Brew Coffee Makers in 2017

There are many different ways to brew and drink around the globe, and each culture claims that their coffee is the best!

Australia, Japan, Germany, Canada, and the US are just a few of the places that have grown fond of drinking it cold, and making cold brew at home is much easier now with all of the different product choices out there.

Wondering which brand makes the best cold brew coffee maker and how you should go about choosing one? Read on as our experts share some helpful tips and their opinions of the top five cold brew products currently available on the market.

Top 12 Cold Brew Coffee Makers Ultimate Table

DesignNameAmount of Coffee It BrewsMaterialsRating (1-5)
  1. Cold Brew Coffee Maker 2 quarts Glass, Stainless Steel, Silicone 4.8
  2. French Press Coffee & Tea Maker Complete Bundle 34 ounces Glass, Stainless Steel 4.7
  3. KitchenAid KCM4212SX Cold Brew Coffee Maker 14 servings Stainless Steel, Glass 4.6
  4. Toddy T2N Cold Brew System 56 fluid ounces Plastic, Glass, Rubber 4.6
  5. Airtight Cold Brew Iced Coffee Maker 1.5 liters Glass, Stainless Steel, Silicone 4.5
6. Hario Mizudashi Cold Brew Iced Coffee Pot/Maker 1000 ml Glass, Plastic, Mesh 4.5
7. Takeya Cold Brew Iced Coffee Maker 1 quart Plastic, Mesh 4.5
8. Coffee Panda Cold Brew Coffee Maker 1.3 liters Glass, Plastic, Mesh 4.5
  9. Cold Brew Coffee Maker – 1 Quart Brewed Iced Coffee Maker 1 quart Glass, Stainless Steel, Plastic, Silicone 4.4
  10. Filtron Cold Water Coffee Concentrate Brewer 1.5 liters Plastic, Glass, Rubber 4.4
  11. OXO Good Grips 4-Cup Cold Brew Coffee Maker 4 cups Plastic, Glass 4.3
  12. Ep Cold Brew Caraf Systm 50 ounces Glass, Plastic, Silicone 4.1

What You Need to Know about Materials

The key to choosing the right cold brew coffee maker to understand the materials. Even if you purchase a top-quality bean that tastes amazing when it is brewed hot, you might have a completely different experience in a cold brewer.

The four types of materials that you’ll find in cold brewers are glass, plastic, silicone, and mesh.

  • Glass – There are different types of glass that manufacturers use when it comes to products that come into contact with food, borosilicate glass being one of the best.

If you see that the container is made of this, it is a sign of a quality product.

Borosilicate glass is much more resistant to thermal shock than common glass is, which means that it can handle the sudden change in temperature without exploding or cracking.

You might already own some borosilicate glass products! Pyrex anyone?

  • Plastic – Plastic is not ideal for coffee brewing simply because it absorbs odors and stains.

On the bright side, it does weigh a lot less than glass, but we can assure that the flavor of coffee that doesn’t make contact with any plastic parts will be much better. Even if it is BPA-free plastic – which is better than regular plastic – just won’t allow you to maximize the flavor.

Some products make contact with plastic for part of the brewing process. The Toddy T2N Cold Brew System, for example, has a plastic brewing container on the top and a glass decanter on the bottom. It’s not ideal, but at least half of product allows the coffee to make contact with the glass.

  • Silicone – Silicone is heat resistant, dishwasher-safe, free of petroleum and it can handle temperature changes with ease.

Since it provides such an excellent seal and it doesn’t give off a stinky odor as rubber does, many manufacturers use it at the top of the brewer where you tighten the lid to prevent leaks.

  • Mesh – The mesh used in coffee maker filters isn’t always made of stainless steel, so if a manufacturer makes it a point to tell you that it is, this is a good sign. Stainless steel doesn’t absorb odors, and it is much more durable.

Some may not opt for such high-quality material, choosing to go with a cheaper food-grade nylon instead, but for the sake of taste, the best cold brew coffee maker has a stainless steel mesh filter.

  • Rubber – Usually the only time rubber is used on this type of brewer is for the little stopper that prevents the coffee from flowing down into the carafe.

How Much Coffee Does It Make? – Are you looking for something that can brew a single cup or would you like a brewer that makes larger quantities of coffee?

If you drink a lot of coffee each day or if you need to prepare it for numerous people, then you might consider a unit like the KitchenAid KCM4212SX.

The rest of the units make much smaller quantities, and since it takes so long to steep, you won’t be able to drink another cup for a while once you run out.

Consider a French Press

A high-quality French press like the one from Kitchen Supreme is ideal for cold brew lovers because it works just as well as any of the other brewers on our list and you can use it to brew hot coffee, as well.

Products marketed specifically as “cold brew coffee makers” can’t always handle hot liquids, but with a French press, you don’t even have to worry about temperature.

Read on to see what our experts thought of the best French press for making cold brew coffee on our list.

Top 5 Best Cold Brew Coffee Makers Reviews

1. County Line Kitchen Cold Brew Coffee Maker

It doesn’t get much simpler than a Mason jar and a filter, yet this is one of the best cold brew coffee makers on our list!

Some of you might be wondering whether you can use a 2-quart Mason jar that you have already, and the answer is yes! They sell the filter separately, so you won’t have to purchase the entire kit if you already have one.

One of the main reasons we love this little brewer is the fact that it is not exposed to any plastic.

It is very simple to use: just add the coffee to the filter, pour over your cold water, let it steep overnight, and by morning, it is ready to drink.

Best invention ever!

2. Kitchen Supreme French Press Coffee & Tea Maker

The next best iced coffee maker on our list is the French press we mentioned earlier.

You won’t have to worry about any coffee grounds sneaking past the filters because it has four layers of mesh to help keep all grounds away from the main liquid.

The container is made of German borosilicate glass – Germany is where this type of glass was invented – and the top is made from stainless steel. Again, this is another plastic-free product, which is why it deserves such high praises.

For about the same price as the Mason jar brewer above, this one comes with an extra stainless steel spoon that you can use to stir coffee drinks as well as a coffee or tea scoop that you can use to add coffee to the press. You also get a recipe book with some tasty drink ideas.

French presses are great for those who love a good, strong cup of coffee. Since you brew it longer and the beans have a coarser grind (or at least they should), the flavor is more intense once it is ready to drink.

Just a tip – if you also drink tea, we advise against alternating the two drinks in the same French press since it can have an impact the flavor. Instead, buy two separate French presses and use each one for each specific drink to maximize your coffee or tea drinking experience.

3. KitchenAid KCM4212SX

When you have a line of thirsty coffee drinkers waiting for a cup, you need a brewer like the KitchenAid KCM4212SX. It can make up to 14 cups of cold brewed coffee, and it has a handy little tap on the front so you don’t have to transfer the brew to a separate container once it is ready.

The coffee will never come into contact with plastic since it is made of stainless steel and glass. It even has a carrying handle on the top!

A gadget like this is especially handy in offices or at parties where you know that cold coffee would be appreciated. If you want all of that tasty coffee to yourself, it is compact enough to fit in the refrigerator, and cold brewed coffee will stay fresh for up to two weeks after you brew it.

4. Toddy T2N Cold Brew System

The Toddy is a popular unit for many coffee drinkers, and they have quite a strong reputation in the cold brew world since they have been manufacturing them since 1964.

While the other units focus more on suspending the coffee grounds in the water or pressing them down so they can steep, this brewer works a bit differently.

The coffee and the water sit together in the top container as they steep. When you’re ready to separate the two, you will remove the stopper at the bottom so the water can drain out. There is a filter on the bottom that prevents the coffee grounds from falling through, but you can only use those filters for up to three months. You’ll have to buy replacement filters after that, and the filters on the other units simply needed to be washed between each use.

This isn’t our favorite product since the top part of the unit is made of plastic, but their brewing technique is rather effective. Be sure to follow Toddy’s instructions so you can maximize the coffee flavor!

They show you how to do it in this video.

5. Ovalware Cold Brew Coffee Maker

The final brewer we would like to suggest will make you feel like you’re whipping up something in the chemistry lab rather than a few cups of coffee, but then again, food preparation is all about the chemistry!

It works like most of the other cold brewers on the list where you add the coffee in the filter and then submerge it in the water. They used a very fine medical-grade stainless steel mesh filter and borosilicate glass for the beaker – both important features.

Even though they used a fine mesh on this one, we still found a few grounds that managed to sneak their way through, which was rather annoying since this ruins the coffee drinking experience.

If you enjoy using coarsely ground beans and like a weaker coffee, then this might be a good match for you. If you like stronger coffee, we still recommend the French press.